The 'Post-' Pindrop
Postmodernism and International Relations Theory
It seems impossible today to leaf through any social science journal and
not encounter at least on article on the topic of 'post-'somethingism,
whether it be postmodernism, poststructuralism, postindustrialism, or
postcolonialism. Nor is it possible to read through a social science
bibliography without witnessing the 'Foucault
effect', or being frightened by the 'Spectre of Derrida', or being
subjected to some 'hyperreal' simulation of Baudrillard.
Even International Relations,
permanent residence of men, states, and wars, is not exempt from the
'interpretive turn' in social sciences.
This limited bibliography serves two related purposes:
To Show how recent International Relations has
dealt with the
linguistic trend in social thought.
To Highlight the work of some 'postmodernist'
thinkers which might
be relevant to a discipline often preoccupied with anarchic anti-social
structures.
Not all of what follows can / nor necessarily should be
classified as 'post-'something-'ism', but all are in my opinion
instructive additions to traditional international relations theorizing.
Along with each cite I am working on including a short blurb on what to
expect in the resource. What I lack in comprehensiveness,
hopefully I will make up for in clarity.
With this in mind...
Arbitrary categories
-
Postmodernism / International Relations (I.R.)
Overview
Authors:
Der Derian, James.
Derrida, Jacques.
Klein, Bradley.
Luke, Timothy.
Virilo, Paul.
Walker, R.B.J.
Internet / Information
Technology.
Or
escape back home . . .
'Epistemology,' 'Ontology,' The Oxford
Companion to Philosophy, Ted Honderich (ed.) Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 1995.
This companion is a
virtual necessity for any undergraduate student attempting to wade their
way thought the myriad of prefixes, suffixes, -isms, and -ists that
populate the rhetoric of philosophy.
Ashley, Richard. 'The Geopolitics of Geopolitical
space: toward a
critical social theory of
International Politics.' Alternatives, XII 1987 p403-434.
In one of the first
full length 'postmodernist' pieces on international relations ever to be
written, Richard Ashley argues that both international politics and the
modern state have constructed a discourse in which specific geographical
lines are drawn around the globe. Ashley argues that the construction of
these borders and the geopolitical culture that accompanies them are
crucial areas of international politics that need to be investigated by
using interpretive techniques such as 'geneaologies', as developed by
Nietzsche and Foucault.
Roy, Rashmary, RBJ Walker, and Richard Ashley.
'Diaglogue: Towards a Critical Social
Theory of International Politics.' Alternatives. XIII, 1988
p77-102.
These three
short pieces serve as follow up comments to Ashley's previous essay.
Rashmary Roy argues for a more foundationalist approach to international
politics which stresses the actual dynamics of power rather than the
nebulous world of discourse. Walker points out some
of the gaps in Ashley's argumentation, although he is sympathetic to
Ashley's approach. Finally, Ashley's response
clarifies and
expounds on his notions of discourse & power, and the political techniques
used to negotiate the relationship between the two.
Ashley, Richard. 'Eye of Power.'
International Organizations. V37 N3, 1983 p495-535.
Bartelson, Jens. A Genealogy of
Sovereignty.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995.
Despite being one of the most commonly assumed 'reality' in
international relations, sovereignty, Bartelson argues, has changed and
developed over a long period of contentious historical
time.
Booth, Ken and Steve Smith.
International Relations Theory Today. Cambridge: Polity 1995.
This collection of essays edited by Ken Booth and Steve Smith is both
useful in terms of the variety of perspectives it offers and in terms of
the issues which it addresses. Examples include Booth's introductory essay
where he attempts to describe the trends in international theory that
include but also go beyond the 'great debates' between idealism and
realism, John Vasquez's essay which points to some of the dangers in
assuming that such enlightenment ideas such as rationality are
analytically useless in an emerging field such as international relations,
and J. Ann Tickner's essay on the changing nature of security in the
post-cold war world, which includes discussions of third world, feminist,
and postmodernist criticisms of theories which emphasize the 'balance of
power.'
Campbell, David. 'Global Inscription: How Foreign
Policy Constitutes the United States.'
Alternatives, XV 1990 p263-286.
In this article, David Campbell argues that U.S. Foreign Policy has been
important not only in its ability to 'secure' the United States from
objective foreign enemies but also in its inability to define and eliminate
domestic enemies as well.
Chaloupka, William. Knowing Nukes: The politics
of culture of the atom. Minneapolis: Univer.
Minnesota Press, 1992.
Connolly, William E. Identity/Difference:
democratic negotiations of political paradox. Ithaca:
Cornell University Press, 1991.
A clear and interesting dialogue about what 'democracy' and ethics mean
form a post-modern perspective. An excellent attempt to provide an answer
to what moral system might emerge from an interpretive perspective.
Dalby, Simon. 'Geopolitical Discourse: the Soviet
Union as Other', Alternatives, v13 1988, p415-442.
In this comprehensive article, Dalby discusses the way in which the
literature regarding nuclear deterrence during the early 1980s described
and proscribed a particular geopolitical and representational relationship
between the Soviet Union and the United States, in which the Soviet Union
is demonized as the 'other.'
Dallmayr, Fred. 'The politics of nonidentity:
Adorno, postmodernism, and Edward Said.'
Political Theory. V25 N1, Feb 1997, p33-56.
Dallmayr argues that a certain ironically-positioned 'non-identity', to
borrow Adorno's terminology, needs to be found. Dallmayr uses Edward
Said's works on post-colonial identity as the basis for such a
reconstitute project.
Devetak, Richard,
'The Project of Modernity and International Relations Theory.' Millennium.
1995 v24 n1 pp27-51.
This piece by Devetak serves not only as a useful
introduction to literature on modernity, but
also attempts to flesh out the debate within the literature between those
who would completely abandon Enlightenment notions of rationality and
those who hold on to the ideals of modernity.
Krause, Keith and Michael C. Williams (eds.),
Critical Security Studies. Minneapolis: Univ. Of
Minnesota 1997.
This volume includes a useful overview regarding exactly what traditions
inform 'critical security studies.' In addition to the theoretical
chapters, which address the current issue of what 'new' issues of security
might be, there are a number of issue focused, empirical chapters,
including a piece by Beverly Crawford about economic security.
Neufield, Mark. The Restructuring of
International
Relations Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 1995.
Neufield attempts to develop a systematic critique of positivist research.
For each point in his critique critique, such as the lack of notions of
agency or culture within a strictly materialistic positivist orientation,
he draws parallels to recent I.R. debates, in this case, whether or not
international regimes are built on instrumental cooperation or on some
normative shared understanding.
Price, Richard.
The Chemical Weapons Taboo. Ithica: Cornell Univ. Press, 1997.
A constructivist scholar's take on the issue of why, even during periods
of intense conflict, there seems to have been a multilateral prohibition
on the use of chemical weapons of mass destruction.
Rogin, Michael.
Ronald Reagan, the movie, and other episodes in political demonology.
Berkeley: University of California Press, 1987.
This study traces the way in which particular political leaders develop
and legitimize their political authority.
Shapiro, Michael. 'Strategic Discourse/Discursive
strategy:
the representation of security policy
in the video age.' International Studies
Quarterly. 1990 Vol 34, p327-340.
This essay attempts to trace the way in which 'security' has changed in an
era in which the West's images of who is insecure and who is doing the
securing is largely mediated by television and other forms of mass media.
Shapiro, Michael. 'That Obscure Object of
violence: Logistics and Desire in the Gulf War.' In
D. Campbell and M. Dillion, The Political Subject of Violence. New York: St. Martin's Press,
1993.
This essay is a detailed reading of Luis Bunuel's classic piece of French
cinema 'That Obscure Object of Desire' and the coverage of the Gulf War by
Western media. The analysis contains specific psychoanalytic language,
following mostly
Lacan, and contains a number of specific references to the movie.
_Return to Contents_
Authors
James Der Derian
Huysmans, Jef. 'James Der Derian: the unbearable
lightness of theory.' The Future of
International Relations. Ole Weaver (ed.), New York: Routledge, 1997.
An useful overview of DerDerian's works with some critical observations.
Der Derian, James. 'The CIA, Hollywood, and
Sovereign Conspiracies.' Queen's Quarterly.
V100, N2 Summer 1993.
An excellent article which attempts to trace certain trends in the nature
of the political representation of international relations through
Hollywood spy films. Among the films examined is Sydney Pollack's '3 Days
of the Condor'. DerDerian pays particular attention to the elements of
secrecy and conspiracy which is common in spy films, and what such
ideological dispositions such tropes betray.
Der Derian, James. Antidiplomacy: Spies, Terror,
Speed, and War. New York: Blackwell, 1992.
A collection of DerDerian's rescent essays, with some revision and new
material. After theoretical overviews about 'espionage' 'terrorism' and
'speed', DerDerian includes a long chapter analysing the specific coverage
of the cold war in terms of the Western media. A disparate yet useful
collection.
Der Derian, James. 'A Reinterpretation of Realism:
Geneaology, Semiology, Dromology.' In
James Der Derian (ed.), International Theory: Critical Investigations. New York University
Press, 1995.
The conclusion of Der Derian's edited collection which attempts to
synthesize the historical debates in IR theory and offer a
'reinterpretation' of the discipline based upon post-modern theoretical
insights.
Der Derian, James.
Diplomatics - Review of J. DerDerian's Antidiplomacy.' By P. Burgess.
Critical Theory.
A fairly lauditory review of Der Derian's _Antidiplomacy_.
Der Derian, James. 'The QDR, the Theater
of War, and Building a Better Rat-Trap.'
A critique of recent Department of Defense efforts to redefine the mission
of the armed services, the efforts was called the Quadrennial Review
(QDR). Insightful not only in terms of pointing to the ways in which
post-Cold War realities do not always mesh with the Department of
Defense's version of 'global threats' but also in terms of what it means
to search for threats in the first place,
Der Derian, James. ;
'Speed Pollution:
Interview with Paul Virillo." Wired, issue 4.05.
Der Derian's interview with French theorist Paul
Virilio.
Der Derian, James. On Diplomacy:
Geneaology of Western Estrangement.
Oxford: Basil Blackwell 1987.
A history of Western diplomacy through the lense of political theoires of
'alienation' and 'estrangement'.
Der Derian, James and Michael Shapiro.
International/Intertextual Relations: postmodern
readings of world politics. New York: Lexington 1989.
A groundbreaking collection of essays which attempt to elucidate what a
'postmodern' project in IR theory might (or might not) look like.
Der Derian, James.
'Cyber-Deterrence.'
Wired. Issue 1.
A discussion of the effects of information technology on the way in which
'war' will be fought in coming decades. Der Derian uses his visit to Fort
Irwin in California to observe war games as the hueristic basis for his
analysis.
Der Derian, James, 'The Simulation Syndrome: From
War Games to Game Wars,' Social Text,
v24 1990.
Der Derian, James, 'The value of Security: Hobbes,
Marx, Nietzsche, and Baudrillard.' In D.
Campbell and M. Dillion, The Political Subject of Violence. New York: St. Martin's Press,
1993.
Der Derian, James. 'The (S)pace of International
Relations: Simulation, Surveillance, and
Speed.' International Studies Quarterly. V34, 1990, p295-310.
Der Derian, James. 'Global Swarming, virtual
security, and Bosnia.' Washington Quarterly. Vol
19 No 3 Summer 1996.
DerDerian, James, 'Arms, Hostages, and the
Importance of Shredding in Earnest: Reading the
National Security Culture', Social Text, v22 Spring 1989.
_Return to Contents_
Jacques Derrida
Writing in reverse: deconstruction on the net
This page is a
collection / archive of a number of Derrida's works, comments on Derrida's
works, and interpretations of Derrida's relevance to writing in
informationalized environments. It is part of a larger 'Hydra' of
information about post-ish philosophers in general.
Jacques
Derrida Bibliography
A bibliography of
Jacques Derrida's works maintained by the UC Irvine Critical Theory
Resource, which compiles and maintains bibliographies on a number of
post-ish writers.
Jacques Derrida
Bibliography
Done by the same people at 'Hydra', this bibliography is searchable both
by title of the work and by the date of the work. Also includes a
bibliography of audio and video works done about or by Derrida. 'Also on
offer' are bibliographies of other authors commentaries on Derrida's
Glas and Spectres de Marx.
Derrida, Jacques, 'No Apocalypse, Not now'.
Diacritics, Summer 1984, Vol 14, No 2.
Derrida's one contribution to issues of international relations,
specfically nuclear criticism.
Norris, Christopher. 'Logic and
rhetoric.' Derrida. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press,
1987.
Christopher Norris's book length discussion of Derrida's project. His
section on "Logic and rhetoric" includes a discussion of the 'No
Apocalypse, Not now' article.
_Return to Contents_
Bradley S. Klein
Klein, Bradley S., 'After Strategy: The search for
a post-modern politics of peace.' Alternatives,
XIII 1988, p293-318.
Klein. Bradley. Strategic studies and world
order. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
1994.
_Return to Contents_
Timoth W. Luke
Luke, Timothy, Screens of Power: Ideology,
Domination, and Resistance in Informational
Society. Urbana: University of Chicago 1989.
Luke, Timothy. 'Power and Politics.' Social
Science Journal. V28 N3, 1991, p347-67.
Luke, Timothy. 'The Discipline of Security Studies
and the Codes of Containment.'
Alternatives. V16 N3 Summer 1991, p315-344.
Luke, Timothy. 'On Post-War: the Significance of
Symbolic Action in Deterrence.' Alternatives,
XIV 1989 p343-362.
Luke, Timothy W. 'Discourses of Disintegration.'
Alternatives, 18 (1993), p229-258.
_Return to Contents_
Paul Virilio
_Speed_ Magazines
Special-Issue on Virilio
_Speed_ is an
excellent online journal which mixes inventive formating with useful and
informative articles. This special issue has been designed to resemble a
search engine, and contains a lengthy list of articles, some in German and
French. Especially interesting is the interview with James Der
Derian.
Enterprise Virilio Page.
A German page
which includes a short biography of Virilio and a few essays, mostly about
Virilio's theories about space and travel.
Wilbur, Shawn. ; 'Dromologies:
Paul Virilio.'
Virilio, Paul. 'The Third Interval: A Critical
Transition.' in Rethinking Technologies. Chapter 1,
Minneapolis: University of Minnesota 1993.
Virilio, Paul. In Der Derian, James (ed)..
The Virilo Reader. New York: Blackwell,
forthcoming.
Virilio, Paul. 'Critical reflections.'
Artforum.
V34 N3, Nor. 1995, p82-84.
_Return to Contents_
R.B.J. Walker
Hansen, Lene. 'RBJ Walker and International
Relations: deconstructing a discipline.' The
Future of International Relations. Ole Weaver (ed.), New York: Routledge, 1997.
Walker, RBJ. Inside/Outside: international
relations as political theory. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 1990.
Walker, R.B.J., 'Culture, Discourse,
Insecurity,'Alternatives, XI 1986, p485-504.
_Return to Contents_
Alexander Wendt
Wendt, Alexander, 'Collective Identity Formation
and the international state.' American
Political Science Review. V88 No 2 June 1994.
Wendt, Alexander. 'Consturcting international
politics.' Journal of International Security. Vol
20 No 1 Summer 1995.
_Return to Contents_
Internet and Information Technology
Balsamo, Anne. 'Forms of Technological Embodiment:
Reading the Body in Contemporary
Culture.' In M. Featherstone and R. Burrows (eds.), Cyberspace/Cyberbodies/Cyberpunk:
Cultures of Technological Embodiment. London: SAGE Publications 1995.
Clark, Nigel , 'Rear-View Mirrorshades: the
recursive generation of the cyberbody.' In M.
Featherstone and R. Burrows (eds.), Cyberspace/Cyberbodies/Cyberpunk: Cultures of
Technological Embodiment. London: SAGE Publications 1995.
Edwards, Paul. The Closed World: Computers and
the Politics of Discourse in Cold War
America. Cambridge: MIT Press 1996.
Forum: 'From print culture to electronic culture,'
'Learned Inquiry and the Net,' 'Electronic
communications and communities,' in Antiquity, V71, N274, December 1997.
Lupton, Deborah. 'The Embodied Computer/User,' In
M. Featherstone and R. Burrows (eds.),
Cyberspace/Cyberbodies/Cyberpunk: Cultures of Technological Embodiment. London: SAGE
Publications 1995.
Nunes, Mark, 'Jean Baudrillard in cyberspace:
Internet, virtuality, and postmodernity.' Style,
V29 N2, Summer 1995, p314-328.
Poster, Mark, 'Postmodern Virtualities.' In
Featherstone and Burrows (eds.),
Cyberspace/Cyberbodies/Cyberpunk. London: SAGE Publications, 1995.
Poster, Mark. The Mode of Information:
Poststructuralism in Social Context. Chicago: Univ.
Of Chicago Press, 1990.
Poster, Mark.
'Interview:
Community, New Media, Post-humanism.' ; Undercurrents.
Robins, Kevin. 'Cyberspace and the World We Live
In,' In M. Featherstone and R. Burrows
(eds.), Cyberspace/Cyberbodies/Cyberpunk: Cultures of Technological Embodiment. London:
SAGE Publications 1995.
_Return to Contents_
Feminist Theory and International Relations
Christine, Sylvester. Feminist Theory and
International Relations in a Postmodern Era.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 1992.
Sylvester, Christine. 'Gender in International
Relations: Feminist Perspectives on Achieving
Global Security.' American Political Science Review, Sept 1993 v87 n3.
_Return to Contents_
|