The winner is B!  University Plaza Townhomes.  Two floors, complete with garage, balcony, and a swimming pool... my new apartment is right next to the University of Redlands.  Only about 5 minutes from work.

Reasons: A was too... ugly

C was just too far away.  about 25 minute commute without traffic.  too bad.

D was much dirtier in person.

B is a bad picture that doesn't do it justice.  Plus, its right in the middle of town.  A great location.  YAY!